Very good quality food. Very fresh and delicious sushi...quite affordable too. BBQ boneless pork was some of the best I ever had. I would say the eating experience was memorable.
The issue with Atami is the human interaction. Talking on the phone is pretty much impossible. Even talking in person, their English is so broken, that we had to resort to pointing to parts of my order printed out to get the point across. In my interaction, I understood maybe one word out of 20, and I am not exaggerating. I am pretty good at understanding accents due to my profession, but this was very difficult and frustrating for me. I recommend ordering the food online. There is a much better chance of getting your order correct.
Overall, I would return, as long as I had ordered ahead online.